News

Man Who Wants Both A Vagina & Penis Wins Funding For Surgery (Photos)

A court has ruled Ontario must pay for a penis-sparing vaginoplasty for a person who identifies as neither fully female nor fully male.

Ontario has been ordered to pay for surgery for a resident who is seeking to have a vagina constructed while leaving their penis intact.

Denying the procedure would infringe on the person’s Charter-protected right to security of the person, an Ontario court said in its ruling.

The unanimous decision by a three-member panel of judges of Ontario’s Divisional Court could expand access to a novel “bottom surgery” for people who identify as non-binary, meaning neither fully male nor fully female.

The Ontario resident, identified in court documents as K.S., has been locked in a legal battle with the Ontario Health Insurance Plan since 2022, when OHIP denied a funding request to have a penile preserving vaginoplasty performed at a clinic in Austin, Texas.

The surgery, which is not available anywhere in Canada, involves creating a vaginal canal, or opening, without removing the penis.

K.S., 33, was born male but identifies as female dominant and uses a feminine name.

OHIP denied her request for funding, arguing that the procedure is not included on its list of sex-reassignment procedures, and is therefore not an insured service.

K.S. appealed OHIP’s decision to Ontario’s Health Services Appeal and Review Board, arguing that forcing her to have her penis removed would invalidate her identity and be akin to an illegal act of conversion therapy.

She also worried about the risk of complications and urinary incontinence from the urological rerouting, and the risk of orgasm dysfunction. She argued the procedure she is seeking abroad is like standard vaginoplasties performed in Ontario, but without the additional procedure, namely, the penectomy.

The appeal board overturned OHIP’s decision, ruling that a vaginoplasty is among the genital surgeries listed for public coverage and need not inherently include removal of the penis. The board therefore ruled the procedure eligible for public funding.

OHIP appealed the board’s decision to the Divisional Court, arguing the review board erred in finding a penis-sparing vaginoplasty is specifically listed as an insured service, and that it failed to consider that the unorthodox procedure is considered an experimental procedure in Ontario, and, therefore, not eligible for funding.

Just because vaginoplasty is listed as an insured service doesn’t mean any type of vaginoplasty qualifies, OHIP argued in court.

The court disagreed. Vaginoplasty and penectomy are listed as discrete, separate services on Ontario’s list of surgeries eligible for funding, the court said. “The fact that most people who have a vaginoplasty have it done in a way that also involves a penectomy” doesn’t change the provision. If the province had intended for only one type of vaginoplasty to be insured (vaginoplasty with penis removal) it should have drafted the list differently, the court said.

The court said the appeal board’s conclusion was also consistent with standards of care developed by the World Professional Association for Transgender Health (WPATH) — an influential group whose guidelines for gender-affirming care for children and youth were found to lack “developmental rigour” in a sweeping review released this week.

thepublisherngr

Recent Posts

#OndoElection2024: See Ondo State Election 2024 Results from Polling Units As Aiyedatiwa Leads

Ondo State Election 2024 Results from polling units have started coming in. The Publisher Nigeria reports…

6 hours ago

Move To Job Sites Or Face Termination Of Contracts – Umahi Issues Ultimatum To Contractors

The Minister of Works, David Umahi, has threatened to discontinue the contracts of contractors in Niger…

6 hours ago

2027: “Stop keeping the company of alcoholics” – Atiku camp hits back at Makinde

A two-time Director of Youth Mobilisation in the Atiku Abubakar Presidential Campaign in 2019 and…

6 hours ago

BREAKING: Tinubu Hosts Indian Prime Minister,Modi

President Bola Ahmed Tinubu will welcome Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi for a State Visit at the…

1 day ago

Breaking: Governor Dapo Abiodun’s Ex Aide Released From US Prison, To Be Deported

A former aide to Governor Dapo Abiodun of Ogun State, Abidemi Rufai has been released…

1 day ago

Former APC Presidential Aspirant Evicted From Abuja House Over Unpaid Rent (VIDEO)

Tunde Omosebi, a former All Progressives Congress (APC) presidential aspirant in the 2023 elections, has…

1 day ago